When my husband died in 2019, I thought I had a secret to avoiding grief. During Ian’s ten months of colon cancer treatment, his oncology fellow and I developed a nascent friendship. After Ian died, I imagined I was in love with the fellow.
Over the course of the next year, my relationship with the fellow deepened as he got to know my two daughters and even our small dog. Though there was nothing overtly romantic between us, our occasional texts and coffee meetups were a pleasurable distraction—just enough to protect me from having to confront my feelings about Ian’s death.
During the pandemic that followed, our friendship began to drift. Perhaps he sensed my growing feelings, or maybe he thought my daughters and I needed him less as time went on. Late one night, I asked him how he felt.
Out of his rejection came this very public essay in The Cut.
Why do writers share their work? And why do we not only share our words, but often our most embarrassing secrets and blunders? I wonder about this a lot. It took me years to express what had happened outside a select group of friends, and to my mother, who assured me that I was normal, though I felt anything but. It didn’t feel normal to be widowed at age 43 or to fall in love with—and act on—feelings for my late husband’s young doctor.
But when long walks and Taylor Swift’s Red (Taylor’s Version) on repeat didn’t do the trick, I took my heartache to the page. It was not unlike birthing a baby over the course of two days. It felt hot and urgent. And though the initial draft excluded key details—that my marriage had been in trouble before Ian was diagnosed with cancer, that the fellow had at least one subsequent relationship with another widow—writing the essay felt cathartic.
I could have put it into a proverbial desk drawer then and just appreciated the exercise. Instead, I submitted it to the New York Times’ Modern Love column. Even then, I questioned my impulse not only to share my secret but to share it with a large audience. Yes, I was writing a memoir that I hoped to publish someday, and yes, the legitimacy the paper could offer was enticing, but what else? I wasn’t arrogant enough to think that my story would help anybody, but I think I was looking for connection. Maybe I wasn’t the only widow who’d found herself infatuated with the wrong person after her partner died.
When the rejection came four months later, I was almost more relieved than disappointed. Disappointed that my carefully imitated Modern Love prose didn’t get chosen, but relieved that I wouldn’t have to face any fallout over it. I decided I wasn’t ready after all. It was so vulnerable and there was a whole list of people I didn’t want to see it—my colleagues, Ian’s family, my ex-boyfriend, the fellow.
Over the next five years, the essay went into and out of the desk drawer several times. I pulled it out for an essay-writing class and my grad school application. Once I was in grad school, I showed it to a few mentors. At one point, after filling in more details about my flailing marriage and fixing my original too-pat ending, it swelled to nearly double its original size. I submitted it to Narratively, where I thought it could live unobtrusively and respectably, but they rejected it on the pitch—too “internal.” It sat for another year and a half.
In December 2025, I graduated with my MFA. By then I had about two thirds of a manuscript written, and the essay represented the middle part. I needed to find a home for it if I ever hoped to publish my memoir. After a pitch class and another rejection, I was thrilled when it was eventually accepted by The Cut.
During my initial call with the editor, she asked what it had been like to write the essay, and something I’d purposefully omitted from the draft tumbled easily out of my mouth: The fellow also had a friendship with another widow, and he later published an essay about her, just as he’d written one about my husband. The editor wanted my essay to hinge on this fact, but I struggled mightily to include it, almost telling her at the last hour that I couldn’t make it happen.
I’d been working hard to shelter the fellow, not just by obscuring his identity, but also by protecting his character. After wrestling with it for the better part of a week—everything I wrote sounded bitter or like I was out to get him—I ran it by a trusted mentor, who suggested turning it into a scene. Where were you and what were you doing when you saw his essay about the other widow? she asked. Keep the focus on you. I pressed my way in. In the end, the scene was edited out, but the details remained.
Maybe I wasn’t the only widow who’d found herself infatuated with the wrong person after her partner died.
By the night before my essay was to go live, I was terrified. Both because of the comments section, which I’d been studying, and because I was fretting that the fellow might see it. I didn’t feel I’d done anything wrong, but I dreaded the discomfort of hearing from him. I’d spoken with mentors, trusted friends, even my therapist, and decided not to reach out. It seemed unnecessary to destabilize his life—and mine—in whatever small way, for an essay he may never see.
And then things took off. Doctors, widows, and cancer survivors left long supportive comments. A few men left mean ones. New York Magazine made it its “One Great Story” to read that day. An agent contacted me. Friends told me it was being discussed in medical Reddit groups—an ideal outcome, since the essay posed what I thought were legitimate questions about the boundaries between doctors and patients.
“Truly, you could not have waterboarded this story out of me!” one commenter wrote. Boy, did I relate. I was kind of shocked that after five years, I’d not only shared it outside of my mother and small group of friends, I’d seemingly showed my underwear to the entire internet.
Reading all of this, despite the interest from the agent and full-throated support from friends and other writers, I was beginning to feel mentally unwell, an accusation heartily endorsed by a few in the comments section. At one point, I found my mother and my 15-year-old daughter had jumped into the fray, defending my honor.
The most unpredictable part was that people were trying to find the fellow, even going as far as sharing (blessedly incorrect) search terms. I became somewhat obsessed with whether I should contact him and let him know what was happening. But what would I say? I’m sorry? I wasn’t sorry for sharing my story. I read the article again, trying to figure out where I’d left breadcrumbs (“for revenge,” a few commenters alleged). I decided I’d been fair to him, and after about two weeks I let go of it entirely. He knew where to find me if he had feelings about what I wrote, though my guess was that he was as ready to put this to bed as I was. Developing outside friendships with deceased patients’ families had to be, at this point, more trouble than it was worth.
A writer in my co-writing group asked recently how I’m feeling about it now. Did I have regrets? Was I proud of myself?
I had just emerged from the comments section for the first time since the essay came out, looking for the “waterboarding” comment to be sure I’d captured it correctly. The newer comments were gentler, and the more empathetic ones had risen to the top as people upvoted them. But I still felt like I needed a cold shower.
In the end, I don’t have regrets. And I am proud of myself, for not only getting it out into the world but into a place I regularly read and once thought out of my reach. The editor genuinely made the piece better by pushing for more details. The flip side is that it’s never easy to put your worst moments on display and invite the world to weigh in.
Why do writers share what they write? Because if we’ve done our jobs, taking the risk earns us connection with other people.
That happened to me.
I felt that way too.
We feel less alone, and maybe somebody else does too. And then we do it all over again.
–
Molly Saint-James is a writer in Baltimore. Her work has appeared in Salon, Baltimore Weddings, and The Cut. She is working on a memoir about middle-aged marriage, widowhood, and grief.
Cover image credit: “Spotlight Marbles” by Chris Potako is licensed under CC BY 2.0.

